Musicians call it the sophomore slump. The pressure of creating and releasing the follow-up to a successful debut. That’s the problem Marc Gurman and Jamie McBride faced when they started thinking about opening a second venue.
Because how do you top Gilson? When it opened in 2016, the elegant all-day diner was instantly embraced by South Yarra. Before long, it was difficult to imagine a time when Gilson hadn’t been a neighbourhood favourite. It was just that mature, confident and competent straight out the gates.
It’s a tough act to follow. No wonder The Frog Club took 10 years.
“Our second venue after Gilson was a long time coming,” Gurman says. “But we thought the time was right for what we wanted to bring to Melbourne for the next project.”
It was worth the wait. Turns out lightning can strike twice. And it’s set to be every bit the local institution that Gilson is. What Gilson was to South Yarra, The Frog Club will be to Windsor.
A lot of places in Melbourne are winding down at 10 o’clock at night. We’re just winding up then. So it’s great. It’s a very exciting place.”
Marc Gurman → Co-owner, The Frog Club
Rooftops to Dive Bars: A Night in Melbourne's Inner South
Bringing Chapel Street’s late-night energy into the dining room
Anyone who’s been on a big night out on Chapel Street knows that compelling late-night eating options on the strip are slim – unless you adore kebabs. That’s the gap that The Frog Club is trying to fill.
“Late night dining was what we wanted to do next,” Gurman says. “At this stage of life, we’re out dining a bit later, putting the kids to bed, coming out and having dinner later.”
“We just thought there was something in the market for it and we wanted to bring it – so the whole menu is available till 12 o’clock at night.”
And it’s some menu.
Gurman and McBride wanted to create a space that nods, nudges and winks at some of their favourite bars and restaurants from around the world.
It’s like a London hotel restaurant met a clubby New York steakhouse, with a sprinkling of Tokyo and Paris bar culture in there for good measure. That means steaks – from small fillets up to 800-gram New York strips on the bone. That means lobster frites, chopped salads and crudités. Martinis? Of course. A decadent seafood tower? Obviously.
“Jamie and myself, we love to travel, and these sorts of [global] cities bring the next level of dining,” Gurman says. “We wanted to showcase that to Melbourne and do that here.”
Besides dining quality, all of those global cities have a reputation for top-notch dining – and populations that love to eat that way. Gurman hopes that the Frog Club can start bringing that attitude to Melbourne. Windsor’s the right place to do it.
“This end of Windsor – it just is late night,” Gurman says. “We’re definitely not a nightclub, but we want to bring a late-night energy restaurant to the area.”
Which is why there’s always DJs playing at The Frog Club, and often live music. It’s why the space is designed for comfort, for settling in and making an evening of it. And it’s why the menu’s packed with crowd-pleasers. Most venues open strong and busy and then empty out as the night wears on. Not The Frog Club. It’s a place that builds and builds to a climactic crescendo every night. You won’t want to leave till it’s time to leave.
“A lot of places in Melbourne are winding down at 10 o’clock at night,” Gurman says. “We’re just winding up then.”
You want to cater to everybody. We wanted a very approachable menu, so you can come in here, grab a little bite and a quick drink – or you can sit for four or five hours and bunker down and go through the whole menu. It’s all there.”
Marc Gurman → Co-owner, The Frog Club
Designing a fun time – every time
Eating is fun. And going to a restaurant should be a fun time. Not the sombre experience it can so often turn into when you get to a certain echelon of dining.
Gurman and McBride wanted The Frog Club to be fun and feel fun.
There’s no better example of that than the sundae service. A sweet and theatrical final flourish to your meal there. Ice cream sundaes, your way, prepared for you tableside.
“A little piece of paper comes with a pencil, and you pick your own toppings and pick your base,” Gurman says. “There’s probably, like, a thousand combinations of what you can pick and put together.”
“It just adds to the atmosphere and the playfulness and theatre and it’s a lot of fun at the end of the night – fun for the kids, fun for everybody.”
If, by that point of the evening, you need any more proof that The Frog Club doesn’t take itself too seriously, the sundae service should be the final piece of evidence you need. The sundae service puts your experience in your hands – and the rest of the menu has a similar amount of versatility.
“You want to cater to everybody,” says Gurman. “We wanted a very approachable menu, so you can come in here, grab a little bite and a quick drink – or you can sit for four or five hours and bunker down and go through the whole menu, it’s all there.”
The venue itself is designed to suit a whole host of moods. From the upstairs cocktail bar to the main dining room, every nook and cranny here has been considered – in terms of its own merits and how it fits into the greater whole.
“The brief to the interior designer was to really take a risk in every section,” Gurman says. “Anywhere you sit in the venue, you should be able to sit there all night or move to a different part of the room and have a different experience, but still feel that strong DNA of The Frog Club.”
Every time you come here, you’ll have a different experience. But you’ll also have the same experience. It’ll be different, but familiar. So far, Windsor’s loving that. Having a serious restaurant that doesn’t take itself too seriously – and that stays open till late.
The Frog Club was worth waiting for. And the next venue from the Gurman and McBride won’t take another 10 years – it’s hitting the southside next year. Gilson used to be the tough act to follow, now it’s The Frog Club that casts a long shadow. But this team has all the stuff it takes to pull off a threepeat.
Want to see where a chef’s night out on Chapel Street takes us? Watch the South Side episode of our Good Neighbours series ->![]()