Rathdowne Street is one of the most important streets in both Carlton and its next-door neighbour Carlton North. On the Carlton side, it’s a busy thoroughfare that connects to the stately grandeur of Carlton Gardens. And up the Carlton North end, it’s the neighbourhood’s de facto high street, packed with some of Melbourne’s favourite cafés, restaurants and bars.
But there’s this one long stretch, on the border between the two Carltons that, for the longest time, was a bit of a hospitality desert. One day a restaurant, Capitano, dared to open there. There was also a café, Bloom, which eventually transformed into Fenton Farmhouse. And that was about it.
Then came Bar Bellamy, and everything started to change.
“We’ve always loved Rathdowne Street, and we chose this end because this spot was available, but also – there were just no bars down this end of Rathdowne,” says co-owner Dani Whitehart. “And we were like, there’s a lot of people down here, a lot of thirsty people, we could get them in, you know?”
And get them in they did. When Dani and her husband Oska opened up here back in 2023, this part of Rathdowne was a Carlton afterthought. Part of the necessary trudge between the two burbs. Ever since, it’s become one of the most vital hospo pockets of the whole area. And a whole constellation of exciting venues have followed the Whiteharts’ lead – from the pasta pros at Supernorma to classy corner restaurant Cordelia.
So much so that last year the Whiteharts recently doubled down by opening Melitta Next Door. It’s Bellamy’s Sicilian sequel, and it’s proving just as popular as its older sibling. This part of Carlton used to be somewhere people avoided. Now everyone wants to be here. This is how these two venues helped to turn it into the place to be.
We didn’t want to rely on people coming here for a particular drink, we wanted people to back to Bar Bellamy for the whole experience; for the service; for the people. Knowing that I can get a good drink and a good bite to eat should be a no-brainer.”
Oska Whitehart → Co-owner, Bar Bellamy & Melitta Next Door
Making Your Mark in Melbourne’s Little Italy | Good Neighbours s2 ep3: Carlton & Carlton North
A bar that feels like a good friend
“Bellamy comes from the French bel ami,” says Dani. “It’s an anglicised name for good friend, and that’s what we wanted Bellamy to feel like.”
They nailed it. Bar Bellamy is everything you would want in a good friend. It’s always there to welcome you in. It has a way of cheering you up, no matter what kind of mood you’re in. It makes you feel cool when you hang out together. And, perhaps most importantly of all, it knows how to make you a mean cocktail. Like any friend should.
That’s all thanks to the deep well of hospo experience that Dani and Oska bring to the table. Dani is more from the café world, and has worked at some Inner North staples like Archie’s All Day and the sorely missed Sibling. Oska, meanwhile, is a bartender through and through. He’s shaken and stirred his way through some of Melbourne’s top cocktail institutions like Eau de Vie, Bad Frankie, Gimlet and The Everleigh.
Eau de Vie was foundational – teaching him the flair, flamboyance and theatre that’s intrinsic to good cocktail making. The Everleigh, meanwhile, which was long considered Australia’s finest bar, dialled up his service skills, as well as the finer details of balancing a drink. Both taught him one thing, though: that, at the end of the day, bars are more about connection than drinks.
“It was learning to not only focus on your products, but with the people as well,” says Oska. “Whether that’s the people you work side by side with everyday ort the people that sit in front of you and enjoy your drinks.”
“It’s building that community and really getting to know everyone you’re serving and trying to go a little bit deeper than just ‘Hey, how was your day?’”
That’s the service style you get at Bar Bellamy. Conversations with staff never feel forced, they actually do care about who you are and how you’re going. And they’re committed to showing you a good – and delicious – time.
Through the drinks, that expresses itself most prominently through the cocktails. Since day one, Bar Bellamy has pledged to follow an intriguing rule: it only makes 100 of each signature cocktail. After that, it leaves the menu for good.
“It keeps it creatively challenging and interesting for the team, but it keeps guests interested,” says Dani. “It means that we have to keep pushing, but hopefully it means there’s something new for someone every time they come in.”
“We want people to come into their local and not be like ‘I’ve had this a million times already.’”
And Oska reckons that having menus that always change pulls the focus towards Bellamy itself, rather than what it’s offering.
“We didn’t want to rely on people coming here for a particular drink, we wanted people to go back to Bar Bellamy for the whole experience, for the service, for the people.” he says. “Knowing that I can get a good drink and a good bite to eat should be pretty much a no-brainer.”
Even though Bar Bellamy is first and foremost a bar, you can definitely get that good bite to eat here. The snacky and ever-changing Euro-leaning menu is the perfect counterpart to the drinks. But it’s not a full-fledged restaurant. For that you’ll want to head to Melitta Next Door, which is, well, exactly where it sounds like it is.
We wanted it to feel different – we believe that there’s so many good things happening on this strip. If we’re not adding , we’re subtracting.”
Dani Whitehart → Co-owner, Bar Bellamy & Melitta Next Door
A restaurant that everyone can enjoy – and afford
In a way, Bellamy was accidentally too good. The drinks were too exceptional, the space was too polished, and the food was too on point. What a problem to have.
“I think as Bellamy grew, sometimes people would come in and they would get really dressed up to come in here,” says Dani. “And we’re like, this is still casual.”
“So we thought we needed something just a bit looser, a bit more fun and a bit more accessible – both at a price point level and not being too intimidating.”
Then, auspiciously, the premises next door to Bellamy opened up. And – double auspiciously – it’s a space that Dani and Oska knew well. In their younger years, they used to go to parties in the share house upstairs. Now they had a chance to come back and use the same building to entertain the neighbourhood.
So in 2025, they opened Melitta Next Door, Bellamy’s neighbour and younger sibling. It feels like a house party rave cave filled with tables and chairs, in the most brilliant way.
Once you’ve taken a seat, grab yourself a golf pencil, go through the menu and check off what you want. You’re probably going to want a lot. Because chef Lorena Corso – who made her mark at Melbourne institutions like Anchovy and Napier Quarter – constantly delivers a menu full of Mediterranean bangers.
And though Corso’s Italian, don’t expect to find pasta here. She’s from Sicily – an island that’s been occupied by just about every culture from both sides of the Med for most of its history.
“Sicily is a pretty different island to the rest of Italy,” Corso says. “The food is kind of like a mix of Tunisian, Spanish, French.”
“So I think it would feel like cheating if I was doing pasta and pizza here.”
Instead, Corso does her best work behind the grill. Expect smoky skewers, charred pucks of flatbread glossed with whipped butter, pan-fried squid, barbequed seafood. Little, delicious, things to share with friends.
“This is the food I grew up eating,” says Corso.
Maybe Carlton’s locals will grow up eating it now too, because one of Melitta’s main goals is to be a place that makes restaurant dining accessible to young people. The quality-to-price ratio is exceptional on every dish and cocktails are pre-batched – unlike at Bellamy – to bring prices down further. On evenings like Wine Wednesdays there’s $2 arrosticini skewers, $10 glasses of wine and $5 corkage on BYO bottles all night.
If Bar Bellamy’s the kind of place that Oska and Dani always dreamed of going to, then Melitta is the place they wish they’d had back in the day. They knew that Melitta had to bring something new to the table, just like Bar Bellamy did before it. Because they know this part of Carlton, and they know what it needs.
“We wanted it to feel different; we believe that there’s so many good things happening on this strip,” Dani says. “If we’re not adding, we’re subtracting.”
Want to see where old fuses with new in one of Melbourne’s most iconic neighbourhoods? Watch the Carlton episode of our Good Neighbours series ->
![]()